Equality of coproduct types

Content created by Egbert Rijke, Fredrik Bakke and Jonathan Prieto-Cubides.

Created on 2022-01-27.
Last modified on 2024-02-06.

module foundation.equality-coproduct-types where
open import foundation.action-on-identifications-functions
open import foundation.coproduct-types
open import foundation.dependent-pair-types
open import foundation.fundamental-theorem-of-identity-types
open import foundation.negated-equality
open import foundation.universe-levels

open import foundation-core.contractible-types
open import foundation-core.embeddings
open import foundation-core.empty-types
open import foundation-core.equivalences
open import foundation-core.function-types
open import foundation-core.functoriality-dependent-pair-types
open import foundation-core.homotopies
open import foundation-core.identity-types
open import foundation-core.retractions
open import foundation-core.sections
open import foundation-core.sets
open import foundation-core.torsorial-type-families
open import foundation-core.truncated-types
open import foundation-core.truncation-levels


In order to construct an identification Id x y in a coproduct coproduct A B, both x and y must be of the form inl _ or of the form inr _. If that is the case, then an identification can be constructed by constructin an identification in A or in B, according to the case. This leads to the characterization of identity types of coproducts.


module _
  {l1 l2 : Level} {A : UU l1} {B : UU l2}

  data Eq-coproduct : A + B  A + B  UU (l1  l2)
    Eq-eq-coproduct-inl : {x y : A}  x  y  Eq-coproduct (inl x) (inl y)
    Eq-eq-coproduct-inr : {x y : B}  x  y  Eq-coproduct (inr x) (inr y)


The type Eq-coproduct x y is equivalent to Id x y

We will use the fundamental theorem of identity types.

module _
  {l1 l2 : Level} {A : UU l1} {B : UU l2}

  refl-Eq-coproduct : (x : A + B)  Eq-coproduct x x
  refl-Eq-coproduct (inl x) = Eq-eq-coproduct-inl refl
  refl-Eq-coproduct (inr x) = Eq-eq-coproduct-inr refl

  Eq-eq-coproduct : (x y : A + B)  x  y  Eq-coproduct x y
  Eq-eq-coproduct x .x refl = refl-Eq-coproduct x

  eq-Eq-coproduct : (x y : A + B)  Eq-coproduct x y  x  y
  eq-Eq-coproduct .(inl x) .(inl x) (Eq-eq-coproduct-inl {x} {.x} refl) = refl
  eq-Eq-coproduct .(inr x) .(inr x) (Eq-eq-coproduct-inr {x} {.x} refl) = refl

  is-torsorial-Eq-coproduct :
    (x : A + B)  is-torsorial (Eq-coproduct x)
  pr1 (pr1 (is-torsorial-Eq-coproduct (inl x))) = inl x
  pr2 (pr1 (is-torsorial-Eq-coproduct (inl x))) = Eq-eq-coproduct-inl refl
    ( is-torsorial-Eq-coproduct (inl x)) (.(inl x) , Eq-eq-coproduct-inl refl) =
  pr1 (pr1 (is-torsorial-Eq-coproduct (inr x))) = inr x
  pr2 (pr1 (is-torsorial-Eq-coproduct (inr x))) = Eq-eq-coproduct-inr refl
    ( is-torsorial-Eq-coproduct (inr x)) (.(inr x) , Eq-eq-coproduct-inr refl) =

  is-equiv-Eq-eq-coproduct : (x y : A + B)  is-equiv (Eq-eq-coproduct x y)
  is-equiv-Eq-eq-coproduct x =
    fundamental-theorem-id (is-torsorial-Eq-coproduct x) (Eq-eq-coproduct x)

  extensionality-coproduct : (x y : A + B)  (x  y)  Eq-coproduct x y
  pr1 (extensionality-coproduct x y) = Eq-eq-coproduct x y
  pr2 (extensionality-coproduct x y) = is-equiv-Eq-eq-coproduct x y

Now we use the characterization of the identity type to obtain the desired equivalences.

module _
  {l1 l2 : Level} {A : UU l1} {B : UU l2}

  module _
    (x y : A)

    map-compute-Eq-coproduct-inl-inl :
      Eq-coproduct {B = B} (inl x) (inl y)  (x  y)
    map-compute-Eq-coproduct-inl-inl (Eq-eq-coproduct-inl p) = p

    is-section-Eq-eq-coproduct-inl :
      (map-compute-Eq-coproduct-inl-inl  Eq-eq-coproduct-inl) ~ id
    is-section-Eq-eq-coproduct-inl p = refl

    is-retraction-Eq-eq-coproduct-inl :
      (Eq-eq-coproduct-inl  map-compute-Eq-coproduct-inl-inl) ~ id
    is-retraction-Eq-eq-coproduct-inl (Eq-eq-coproduct-inl p) = refl

    is-equiv-map-compute-Eq-coproduct-inl-inl :
      is-equiv map-compute-Eq-coproduct-inl-inl
    is-equiv-map-compute-Eq-coproduct-inl-inl =
        ( Eq-eq-coproduct-inl)
        ( is-section-Eq-eq-coproduct-inl)
        ( is-retraction-Eq-eq-coproduct-inl)

    compute-Eq-coproduct-inl-inl : Eq-coproduct (inl x) (inl y)  (x  y)
    pr1 compute-Eq-coproduct-inl-inl = map-compute-Eq-coproduct-inl-inl
    pr2 compute-Eq-coproduct-inl-inl = is-equiv-map-compute-Eq-coproduct-inl-inl

    compute-eq-coproduct-inl-inl : Id {A = A + B} (inl x) (inl y)  (x  y)
    compute-eq-coproduct-inl-inl =
      compute-Eq-coproduct-inl-inl ∘e extensionality-coproduct (inl x) (inl y)

    map-compute-eq-coproduct-inl-inl : Id {A = A + B} (inl x) (inl y)  x  y
    map-compute-eq-coproduct-inl-inl = map-equiv compute-eq-coproduct-inl-inl

  module _
    (x : A) (y : B)

    map-compute-Eq-coproduct-inl-inr : Eq-coproduct (inl x) (inr y)  empty
    map-compute-Eq-coproduct-inl-inr ()

    is-equiv-map-compute-Eq-coproduct-inl-inr :
      is-equiv map-compute-Eq-coproduct-inl-inr
    is-equiv-map-compute-Eq-coproduct-inl-inr =
      is-equiv-is-empty' map-compute-Eq-coproduct-inl-inr

    compute-Eq-coproduct-inl-inr : Eq-coproduct (inl x) (inr y)  empty
    pr1 compute-Eq-coproduct-inl-inr = map-compute-Eq-coproduct-inl-inr
    pr2 compute-Eq-coproduct-inl-inr = is-equiv-map-compute-Eq-coproduct-inl-inr

    compute-eq-coproduct-inl-inr : Id {A = A + B} (inl x) (inr y)  empty
    compute-eq-coproduct-inl-inr =
      compute-Eq-coproduct-inl-inr ∘e extensionality-coproduct (inl x) (inr y)

    is-empty-eq-coproduct-inl-inr : is-empty (Id {A = A + B} (inl x) (inr y))
    is-empty-eq-coproduct-inl-inr = map-equiv compute-eq-coproduct-inl-inr

  module _
    (x : B) (y : A)

    map-compute-Eq-coproduct-inr-inl : Eq-coproduct (inr x) (inl y)  empty
    map-compute-Eq-coproduct-inr-inl ()

    is-equiv-map-compute-Eq-coproduct-inr-inl :
      is-equiv map-compute-Eq-coproduct-inr-inl
    is-equiv-map-compute-Eq-coproduct-inr-inl =
      is-equiv-is-empty' map-compute-Eq-coproduct-inr-inl

    compute-Eq-coproduct-inr-inl : Eq-coproduct (inr x) (inl y)  empty
    pr1 compute-Eq-coproduct-inr-inl = map-compute-Eq-coproduct-inr-inl
    pr2 compute-Eq-coproduct-inr-inl = is-equiv-map-compute-Eq-coproduct-inr-inl

    compute-eq-coproduct-inr-inl : Id {A = A + B} (inr x) (inl y)  empty
    compute-eq-coproduct-inr-inl =
      compute-Eq-coproduct-inr-inl ∘e extensionality-coproduct (inr x) (inl y)

    is-empty-eq-coproduct-inr-inl : is-empty (Id {A = A + B} (inr x) (inl y))
    is-empty-eq-coproduct-inr-inl = map-equiv compute-eq-coproduct-inr-inl

  module _
    (x y : B)

    map-compute-Eq-coproduct-inr-inr :
      Eq-coproduct {A = A} (inr x) (inr y)  x  y
    map-compute-Eq-coproduct-inr-inr (Eq-eq-coproduct-inr p) = p

    is-section-Eq-eq-coproduct-inr :
      (map-compute-Eq-coproduct-inr-inr  Eq-eq-coproduct-inr) ~ id
    is-section-Eq-eq-coproduct-inr p = refl

    is-retraction-Eq-eq-coproduct-inr :
      (Eq-eq-coproduct-inr  map-compute-Eq-coproduct-inr-inr) ~ id
    is-retraction-Eq-eq-coproduct-inr (Eq-eq-coproduct-inr p) = refl

    is-equiv-map-compute-Eq-coproduct-inr-inr :
      is-equiv map-compute-Eq-coproduct-inr-inr
    is-equiv-map-compute-Eq-coproduct-inr-inr =
        ( Eq-eq-coproduct-inr)
        ( is-section-Eq-eq-coproduct-inr)
        ( is-retraction-Eq-eq-coproduct-inr)

    compute-Eq-coproduct-inr-inr : Eq-coproduct (inr x) (inr y)  (x  y)
    pr1 compute-Eq-coproduct-inr-inr = map-compute-Eq-coproduct-inr-inr
    pr2 compute-Eq-coproduct-inr-inr = is-equiv-map-compute-Eq-coproduct-inr-inr

    compute-eq-coproduct-inr-inr : Id {A = A + B} (inr x) (inr y)  (x  y)
    compute-eq-coproduct-inr-inr =
      compute-Eq-coproduct-inr-inr ∘e extensionality-coproduct (inr x) (inr y)

    map-compute-eq-coproduct-inr-inr : Id {A = A + B} (inr x) (inr y)  x  y
    map-compute-eq-coproduct-inr-inr = map-equiv compute-eq-coproduct-inr-inr

The left and right inclusions into a coproduct are embeddings

module _
  {l1 l2 : Level} (A : UU l1) (B : UU l2)

    is-emb-inl : is-emb (inl {A = A} {B = B})
    is-emb-inl x =
        ( is-contr-equiv
          ( Σ A (Id x))
          ( equiv-tot (compute-eq-coproduct-inl-inl x))
          ( is-torsorial-Id x))
        ( λ y  ap inl)

  emb-inl : A  (A + B)
  pr1 emb-inl = inl
  pr2 emb-inl = is-emb-inl

    is-emb-inr : is-emb (inr {A = A} {B = B})
    is-emb-inr x =
        ( is-contr-equiv
          ( Σ B (Id x))
          ( equiv-tot (compute-eq-coproduct-inr-inr x))
          ( is-torsorial-Id x))
        ( λ y  ap inr)

  emb-inr : B  (A + B)
  pr1 emb-inr = inr
  pr2 emb-inr = is-emb-inr

Moreover, is-injective-inl and is-injective-inr are the inverses.

module _
  {l1 l2 : Level} {A : UU l1} {B : UU l2}

  is-retraction-is-injective-inl :
    {x y : A} 
    is-retraction (ap (inl {A = A} {B = B}) {x} {y}) (is-injective-inl)
  is-retraction-is-injective-inl refl = refl

  is-section-is-injective-inl :
    {x y : A} 
    is-section (ap (inl {A = A} {B = B}) {x} {y}) (is-injective-inl)
  is-section-is-injective-inl refl = refl

  is-retraction-is-injective-inr :
    {x y : B} 
    is-retraction (ap (inr {A = A} {B = B}) {x} {y}) (is-injective-inr)
  is-retraction-is-injective-inr refl = refl

  is-section-is-injective-inr :
    {x y : B} 
    is-section (ap (inr {A = A} {B = B}) {x} {y}) (is-injective-inr)
  is-section-is-injective-inr refl = refl

A map A + B → C defined by maps f : A → C and B → C is an embedding if both f and g are embeddings and they don't overlap

module _
  {l1 l2 l3 : Level} {A : UU l1} {B : UU l2} {C : UU l3} {f : A  C} {g : B  C}

  is-emb-coproduct :
    is-emb f  is-emb g  ((a : A) (b : B)  f a  g b) 
    is-emb (rec-coproduct f g)
  is-emb-coproduct H K L (inl a) (inl a') =
      ( ap f)
      ( ap (rec-coproduct f g))
      ( ap inl)
      ( ap-comp (rec-coproduct f g) inl)
      ( H a a')
      ( is-emb-inl A B a a')
  is-emb-coproduct H K L (inl a) (inr b') =
    is-equiv-is-empty (ap (rec-coproduct f g)) (L a b')
  is-emb-coproduct H K L (inr b) (inl a') =
    is-equiv-is-empty (ap (rec-coproduct f g)) (L a' b  inv)
  is-emb-coproduct H K L (inr b) (inr b') =
      ( ap g)
      ( ap (rec-coproduct f g))
      ( ap inr)
      ( ap-comp (rec-coproduct f g) inr)
      ( K b b')
      ( is-emb-inr A B b b')

Coproducts of k+2-truncated types are k+2-truncated

module _
  {l1 l2 : Level} (k : 𝕋) {A : UU l1} {B : UU l2}

    is-trunc-coproduct :
      is-trunc (succ-𝕋 (succ-𝕋 k)) A  is-trunc (succ-𝕋 (succ-𝕋 k)) B 
      is-trunc (succ-𝕋 (succ-𝕋 k)) (A + B)
    is-trunc-coproduct is-trunc-A is-trunc-B (inl x) (inl y) =
      is-trunc-equiv (succ-𝕋 k)
        ( x  y)
        ( compute-eq-coproduct-inl-inl x y)
        ( is-trunc-A x y)
    is-trunc-coproduct is-trunc-A is-trunc-B (inl x) (inr y) =
      is-trunc-is-empty k (is-empty-eq-coproduct-inl-inr x y)
    is-trunc-coproduct is-trunc-A is-trunc-B (inr x) (inl y) =
      is-trunc-is-empty k (is-empty-eq-coproduct-inr-inl x y)
    is-trunc-coproduct is-trunc-A is-trunc-B (inr x) (inr y) =
      is-trunc-equiv (succ-𝕋 k)
        ( x  y)
        ( compute-eq-coproduct-inr-inr x y)
        ( is-trunc-B x y)

Coproducts of sets are sets

  is-set-coproduct :
    {l1 l2 : Level} {A : UU l1} {B : UU l2} 
    is-set A  is-set B  is-set (A + B)
  is-set-coproduct = is-trunc-coproduct neg-two-𝕋

coproduct-Set :
  {l1 l2 : Level} (A : Set l1) (B : Set l2)  Set (l1  l2)
pr1 (coproduct-Set (A , is-set-A) (B , is-set-B)) = A + B
pr2 (coproduct-Set (A , is-set-A) (B , is-set-B)) =
  is-set-coproduct is-set-A is-set-B

See also

Recent changes